Transport Layer Security (TLS) handshake renegotiation weak security

Notification Type: IBM Internet Security Systems Protection Alert
Notification Date: November 09, 2009
Notification Version: 1.3
   
Name: Transport Layer Security (TLS) handshake renegotiation weak security
Public disclosure/
In the wild date:
November 04, 2009
CVE: CVE-2009-3555
Description:

Multiple implementations of the Transport Layer Security (TLS) protocol, including SSL, could allow a remote attacker to exploit a handshake renegotiation vulnerability through a man-in-the-middle attack, bypassing authentication and possibly launching further attacks against the victim.

 

ISS Coverage

Product Content Version
Proventia Network IDS
Proventia Network IPS
Proventia Network MFS
Proventia Server (Linux)
RealSecure Network
RealSecure Server Sensor
29.110
Proventia Desktop
Proventia Server IPS (Windows)
2450
Propagation Techniques ISS Protection Available

remote exploit

 

TLS_Client_Cipher_Renegotiation
TLS_Server_Cipher_Renegotiation
TLS_Cipher_Renegotiation
(multiple)

10 Nov 2009

Detailed Description

Business Impact:

This vulnerability involves three attack scenarios, two of which leverage server-initiated SSL ciphersuite renegotiations and one, the most dangerous of the three, which involves a client-initiated SSL ciphersuite renegotiation that is induced by the attacker. The vulnerabilities allow the attacker to prepend data to the client's initial transmission or request. This attack could be use to compromise the security of Web sites that are expected to be protected through SSL/HTTPS.  However, most Web applications, and especially those that might have implemented some type of application-level protection against cross-site request forgery, are unlikely to be configured in a way that is vulnerable to this kind of attack (for more details, see this blog post on FrequencyX.)

In addition, exploitation of this vulnerability requires a man-in-the-middle attack, so attackers must have some way of getting into the traffic stream between the victim client and server. Getting in the middle is easy to accomplish on an open wireless network at an airport or hotel, or on ethernet networks with arp cache poisoning tools such as Cain & Abel or dsniff. Attacks on network infrastructure such as routers or DNS servers could also be leveraged to successfully exploit this issue. Because of the complexity associated with man-in-the-middle attacks, they are not usually widespread.

*CVSS Base Score: 4.0
  Access Vector: Network
Access Complexity: High
Authentication: None
Confidentiality Impact: Partial
Integrity Impact: Partial
Availability Impact: None
Adjusted Temporal Score: 3.4
  Exploitability: Functional
Remediation Level: Temporary Fix
Report Confidence: Confirmed
Affected Products: For a full list of affected versions, see references below.
Technical Description:

Multiple implementations of the Transport Layer Security (TLS) protocol, including SSL, could provide weaker than expected security, caused by TLS handshake renegotiation. A remote attacker could exploit this vulnerability via man-in-the-middle techniques to inject data into the beginning of the application protocol stream to execute HTTP transactions, bypass authentication and possibly launch further attacks against the victim.

Remediation:

Some patches are available that provide a partial fix for this issue (disabling renegotiation, which might affect interoperability in some applications). See References for details.

References

XFDB: http://xforce.iss.net/xforce/xfdb/54158
FrequencyX: http://blogs.iss.net/archive/sslmitmiscsrf.html
http://blogs.iss.net/archive/andwhilewereatit.html
http://blogs.iss.net/archive/stealingcookieswiths.html

Revision History

1.0 Initial publication.
1.1 Updated CVSS Remediation Level from "Workaround" to "Temporary Fix."
1.2 Updated the Remediation section to refer to a partial fix instead of a workaround.
1.3 Added partial confidentiality impact to the CVSS score based on the technique described in the Tom Cross blog post on 11/12/2009.  Added references to the FrequencyX blog.

* According to the Forum of Incident Response and Security Teams (FIRST), the Common Vulnerability Scoring System (CVSS) is an "industry open standard designed to convey vulnerability severity and help to determine urgency and priority of response." IBM PROVIDES THE CVSS SCORES "AS IS" WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, INCLUDING THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. CUSTOMERS ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR ASSESSING THE IMPACT OF ANY ACTUAL OR POTENTIAL SECURITY VULNERABILITY.
The information within this database may change without notice. Use of this information constitutes acceptance for use in an AS IS condition. There are NO warranties, implied or otherwise, with regard to this information or its use. Any use of this information is at the user's risk. In no event shall IBM be held liable for any damages whatsoever arising out of or in connection with the use or spread of this information.

About IBM Internet Security Systems

IBM Internet Security Systems is a trusted security advisor to thousands of the world's leading businesses and governments, helping to provide pre-emptive protection for networks, desktops and servers. The IBM Proventia® integrated security platform is designed to automatically protect against both known and unknown threats, helping to keep networks up and running and shield customers from online attacks before they impact business assets. IBM Internet Security Systems products and services are based on the proactive security intelligence of its X-Force® research and development team – an unequivocal world authority in vulnerability and threat research. The IBM Internet Security Systems product line is also complemented by comprehensive Managed Security Services and Professional Security Services. For more information, visit the IBM Internet Security Systems Web site at www.iss.net or call 800-776-2362.